GTA 5? (Xbox) or Minecraft? (PC)?

GTA 5 for sure

It depends on what you like. I have both.

Grand Theft Auto 5 has an amazing story, the gameplay is amazing, a huge improvement from Grand Theft Auto 4. You will play it for a while. GTA Online is amazing too.

Minecraft will keep you playing for a long time trust me. Once you get into it, the possibilities are limitless. Don't forget mods as well as they may keep you playing for a long time. Creating your own world is just great. After you worked long you may find the building whatever you were building was a great accomplishment. After you feel this feeling of accomplishment all you wanna do is accomplish more.(in my experience)

How are these even comparable

Gta v