The Computer its going in has a overclocked Intel Core i5-8600K and is running windows 10 home 64 bit with 16GB (2x8GB) of DDR4 Corsair ram.
What is the best graphics card for minecraft, gta, and rocket League for 200 dollars or less?
A 1060 would work good for you
What is your power supply by brand and model number for support of cards over 75 watts?
You can get an RX 580 8GB or GTX 1060 3GB but 500W minimum power supply for the RX 580 with an 8 pin pcie power connector generally, and GTX 1060 at least a 450W and a 6 pin pcie.
You don't need a card this strong except for maximum settings on GTA V. GTA V is optimized for NVidia, though most games do better with the RX 580 8GB
With a weak power supply, you either upgrade it, or need a card with no auxilliary power connection.
Most GTX 1050 TI and RX 560 do not need the connect, but each needs checking.
Radeon RX 560 - 896 (Which is an RX 460)
Radeon RX 560 - 1024
GeForce GTX 1050 Ti
The performance difference is large between GTX 1050 TI and GTX 1060 3GB