Best Headphones For Gaming and Music Under $75?

For music, I mainly listen to anime, vocaloid, and orchestral music. And basically, just Japanese music ranging from games (soundtracks) to calm piano covers.

For gaming I'll be playing games like Minecraft, Skyrim, Garry's Mod, and just a bunch of indie games.

I currently have the Sennheiser HD 202 II, but they have broke. Should I just get them replaced(I still have warranty… I think)?

Any decent brand name will do.
But, I suggest that you try to find a pair that has volume controls on each ear piece. You may be surprised to find your hearing has been affect so that each ear needs its own adjustment level.