Dragons dogma vs lotr war in the north vs farcry 3?

I want a new game something close to fallout nv or skyrim. Would like: character creation, survival type stuff, open world, lots of freedom, choices with consequences, very engaging, very high replay value, etc etc. I haven't found a game yet t top skyrim or new vegas and find myself continuously game hopping from skyrim new vegas and minecraft. Out of farcry 3, lotr war in the north and dragons dogma which is the best and why

Dragons dogma. But have you played dead space thats an awsome game and if you like rpgs try mass effect the first one looks a bit old now but the story is really awsome and if you play from one all your decisions carry through to 2 and 3

Three suggestions come to mind that might interest you. These are older games, but they have high replay value.

First "Kingdoms of Amalur: Reckoning" is a game very similar to Skyrim. It is about the same age as Skyrim also.

Then there's "Oblivion" which is the Elder Scrolls game previous to Skyrim. It plays almost like Skyrim but suffers some as far as graphics go. It was released in 2006 I believe.

And "Morrowind" which is also a Elder Scrolls game. Gameplay is quite a bit deeper than either Oblivion or Skyrim, but the graphics are dated since it is a 12-year-old game.

All of the above can be had fairly cheaply these days.