Firstly, I would like to say not Minecraft. Here is the list of boxes to tick:
- fun to play
- fun for audience to watch (i.e. Not Battlefield or CoD)
- solo not co-op
- re-play value (such as Binding of Isaac, except that game is a bit dated)
- original yet famous enough to attract attention
- NOT something 13/14/15 year olds would watch (I don't want an immature audience)
Optional:
- something that makes commentating easier
- not a puzzle game (that will make for dreadful commentary)
If our on. Pc definitely dayz it's a online multiplayer but you are in a zombie apocalypse so you have to find stuff and survive very fun to watch and everytime it's different.
I recommend the Bioshock series. It was suspenseful with twists that with **** your mind and I couldn't put the series down! I beat the entire series in 1 week exact and it's my favorite game series of all time, fun, solo, no puzzles unless you want to hack the machines (you get a hack gun later in the game to prevent doing the puzzles) you can replay it for different endings (save the little sister= good ending/ harvesting even 1 sister =bad ending) each game has a different story but same mind ******* twists that you never expect. I love the game series and highly recommend it to you and your viewers. Best of luck
Tomb Raider, puzzles are optional